Popular Topics

Baked Eyeballs Casserole

Baked Eyeballs Casserole

5 5

The "eyeballs" that top our spooky casserole are made from mozzarella cheese and sliced olives.  But the cheesy, baked pasta that lies below is a real treat that everyone will enjoy.

serves 8 people


cost per recipe: $9.10

The price is determined by the national average.

  • 1

    jar (24 ounces) Prego® Italian Sausage & Garlic Italian Sauce

  • 1

    container (15 ounces) reduced fat (part skim) ricotta cheese

  • 3/4

    cup Parmesan cheese

  • 16

    ounces (1 package) farfalle (bow tie) pasta, cooked and drained

  • 1

    container (8 ounces) small fresh part skim mozzarella cheeseballs (about 1-inch)

  • 2

    tablespoons sliced black olives

view nutrition info

How to Make It

Step 1

Spray a 13 x 9 x 2-inch shallow baking dish with vegetable cooking spray.

Step 2

Mix 1 1/2 cups of the sauce, ricotta cheese, 1/2 cup Parmesan cheese and pasta in the prepared dish. Spread the remaining sauce over the pasta mixture. Sprinkle with the remaining Parmesan cheese and cover the dish with foil.

Step 3

Bake at 400°F. for 25 minutes or until hot and bubbling. Arrange the cheese balls randomly over the pasta mixture. Place a sliced olive on each cheese ball. Let stand for 10 minutes before serving.

Recipe Tips

  • Tip: Easy Substitution Tip: If fresh mozzarella cheese balls are not available, substitute 1 package (8 ounces) fresh mozzarella cheese. Cut crosswise into thirds. Cut each third in 6 wedges, for triangle-shaped eyes.

Assign to a collection

New Collection

remove from favorites

Are you sure you want to remove this recipe from your favorites?


New Collection

Made With
Prego® Italian Sausage & Garlic Italian Sauce

Prego® Italian Sausage & Garlic Italian Sauce

Buy Now

Ratings & Reviews

  • tania p.

    October 20, 2013

    Easy to make and everyone liked it!

    Made the recipe as is and it tasted great! I used a mixture of bow tie and shell pasta because I didn't have enough bow tie and didn't feel like going to the store. Also, you can always add to the recipe by adding fresh basil or oregano to amp up the flavor. Served this with a simple green salad and bread sticks. It was a hit with the family.

    Was this helpful?

    (0) (0)
  • mimi45

    October 30, 2012

    This Recipe is excellent for prehalloween dinner

    This was a very fun recipe to make.The ingredients were everything that a kid loves.They were excited to see the finished casserole and ate the who thing with no problem.I will deffinately make again for halloween and will tell other moms about it.

    Was this helpful?

    (0) (0)
  • Laura S.

    October 31, 2010

    Baked Eyeballs Casserole

    It was good but everyone was scared to try it because of the eye balls. They tried it and had two plates of it!

    Was this helpful?

    (0) (0)
  • brightie

    October 31, 2010

    Baked Eyeballs Casserole

    Easy and entertaining.

    Was this helpful?

    (0) (0)
  • c.l.nordquist

    September 23, 2006

    Baked Eyeballs Casserole

    Oh yeah, this was delicious and gross all at the same time. It is the pefect Halloween Dinner!

    Was this helpful?

    (0) (0)

Your Rating:



  • keep your review focused on the recipe
  • avoid writing about customer service; contact us instead if you have issues requiring immediate attention
  • refrain from mentioning competitors or the specific price you paid for the product
  • do not include any personally identifiable information, such as full names

By submitting, I agree to the terms and conditions.

Thank you for your review!

Please note that your review might take up to 72 hours to appear following submission.

We will let you know when it’s posted by sending you an email.

show less reviews read more reviews →

Recently Viewed